ABC NewsReview: 'The Pale Blue Eye' circles its convoluted plot without finding a satisfying place to land

AP NewsReview: Whodunit 'The Pale Blue Eye' chills and satisfies

The Arizona RepublicHarry Melling nails the most enjoyably offbeat performance of 2022 in 'The Pale Blue Eye'

Chicago Sun-Times‘The Pale Blue Eye’: Christian Bale impresses again as detective partnered with young Edgar Allan Poe

Noah BerlatskyReview: The Pale Blue Eye - Chicago Reader

Datebook | San Francisco Arts & Entertainment GuideReview: Netflix’s ‘Pale Blue Eye’ spooks with Edgar Allan Poe and an explosive twist

The IndependentChristian Bale in the rich if unnecessarily Easter egg-filled Pale Blue Eye – review

Christina NewlandChristian Bale whodunit The Pale Blue Eye is undercooked

The Irish TimesThe Pale Blue Eye: Christian Bale leads a starry cast in a beautifully shot, absurdly plotted movie

LAistFilmWeek: ‘Babylon,’ ‘A Man Called Otto,’ ‘Puss In Boots: The Last Wish’ And More

Little White LiesThe Pale Blue Eye

The Mercury NewsWhat to watch: ‘M3GAN’ wants to be more than another creepy doll story

James MottramThe Pale Blue Eye review: Christian Bale in a grisly murder mystery

Roger EbertThe Pale Blue Eye movie review (2022)

Movie NationNetflixable? Poet Poe and a Dogged Constable ponder grisly murders at West Point — “The Pale Blue Eye”

K. Austin Collins'The Pale Blue Eye': Christian Bale and Edgar Allan Poe Solve Murders on Netflix

The Daily BeastWhen Christian Bale Met Edgar Allan Poe

William Bibbiani'The Pale Blue Eye' Review: Murder Mystery Puts Young Edgar Allan Poe on the Case

Stephanie Zacharek'The Pale Blue Eye' Is a Frosty Murder Mystery

Ty BurrWhat To Watch: Whistling in the Dark Edition

Bilge EbiriThe Pale Blue Eye Is Grisly, Grim, and Surprisingly Moving