Tom MisonIchabod Crane

Lyndie GreenwoodJenny Mills

Nicole BeharieAbbie Mills

Katia WinterKatrina Crane

Orlando JonesCaptain Frank Irving

John NobleHenry Parrish

Zach AppelmanJoe Corbin

Nikki ReedBetsy Ross

Lance GrossDaniel Reynolds

Shannyn SossamonPandora

Oona YaffeMolly Thomas

Janina GavankarDiana Thomas

Rachel MelvinAlex Norwood

Jerry MacKinnonJake Wells

Peter MensahThe Hidden One

Jeremy OwensHeadless Horseman

Neil JacksonAbraham Van Brunt

Matt BarrNick Hawley

Derek MearsMoloch

John ChoAndy Brooks

Craig BranhamHeadless Horseman

Nicholas GonzalezDetective Luke Morales

Clancy BrownSheriff August Corbin

Marti MatulisHorseman of War

Jill Marie JonesCynthia Irving

D.J. MifflinMoloch

Anthony K. HyattRandall Martin

Sakina JaffreySheriff Leena Reyes

Amandla StenbergMacey Irving

Alex SgambatiDani

Patrick GormanReverend Alfred Knapp

Len WisemanCreator

Alex KurtzmanCreator

Roberto OrciCreator