Janet MontgomeryMary Sibley
Shane WestJohn Alden
Seth GabelCotton Mather
Tamzin MerchantAnne Hale
Ashley MadekweTituba
Elise EberleMercy Lewis
Iddo GoldbergIsaac Walton
Oliver BellLittle John
Xander BerkeleyMagistrat Hale
Lucy LawlessCondessa Marburg
Joe DoyleBaron Sebastian Marburg
Samuel RoukinThe Sentinel
Brannon BragaCreator
Adam SimonCreator