Bette MidlerWinifred Sanderson

Sarah Jessica ParkerSarah Sanderson

Kathy NajimyMary Sanderson

Whitney PeakBecca

Belissa EscobedoIzzy

Lilia BuckinghamCassie

Froy GutierrezMike

Sam RichardsonGilbert

Doug JonesBilly Butcherson

Tony HaleMayor / Reverend Traske

Hannah WaddinghamThe Witch Mother

Taylor HendersonYoung Winifred

Nina KitchenYoung Mary

Juju Journey BrenerYoung Sarah

Thomas FitzgeraldJohn Pritchett

Brett CrampMr. Pritchett

Kim NiemiTownsperson

Alison WellerTownsperson

Holly CinnamonTownsperson

Patrick FrenchTownsperson

Charlotte PeedMrs. Smith

Ed PeedMr. Smith

Austin J. RyanYoung Billy Butcherson

Michael TowMr. Wilke

BrinaSchool Secretary

Brian WilesRob

Owen EarlsLiam

Skyla SousaTeen Winifred

Aiden TorresTeen Mary

Emma KaufmanTeen Sarah

Chhoyang CheshatsangThom

Jaylin PryorTeen Gilbert

Marissa CarpioFood Stall Woman

Naheem GarciaFred

Dan FinnertyLucas

Joshua Allan EadsDrag Queen Winifred

Kornbread JetéDrag Queen Mary

Kahmora HallDrag Queen Sarah

Ryan RosenthalGlenn

Juvan ElismaAlex

Jen D'AngeloLiam's Mom

Mark FicheraScary Scarecrow

Jordan von NetzerRoman Soldier

Mark HawkerPuppeteer

Shane DzicekPuppeteer

CJ WalshPuppeteer

Anne FletcherDirector

Jen D'AngeloWriter

Mick GarrisCharacters

Blake HarrisStory

David KirschnerStory & Characters & Executive Producer

Adam ShankmanExecutive Producer

Ralph WinterExecutive Producer

Lynn HarrisProducer