John ChoDavid Kim

Michelle LaMargot Kim

Debra MessingDetective Vick

Joseph LeePeter

Sara SohnPamela Nam Kim

Briana McLeanAbigail

Erica JenkinsHannah Pardy

Connor McRaithIsaac

Dominic HoffmanMichael Porter

Ric SarabiaRandy Cartoff

Steven Michael EichRobert

Melissa DisneyIsaac's Mom (voice)

Sean O'BryanRadio Jockey

Ben CainSVPD Homicide Agent

Alex Jayne GoYoung Margot (5 yrs)

Megan LiuYoung Margot (7 yrs)

Kya Dawn LauYoung Margot (9 yrs)

Colin Woodell911 Operator (voice)

Ashley EdnerMargot's Friend #1 (voice)

Courtney Lauren CummingsMargot's Friend #2 (voice)

Kenneth MosleyMargot's Friend #7 (voice)

Miss BennyMargot's Friend #11 (voice)

Franchesca MaiaSadie (YouCast)

Thomas BarbuscaCody (YouCast)

Sylvia MinassianMrs. Shahinian (voice)

Bryce BranaganDiver #1

Katie RoweDiver #2

Kristin HeroldFemale Anchor

Roy AbramsohnMale Anchor

Reed BuckDerek Ellis (voice)

Brad AbrellNews Reporter (voice)

Rasha GoelSearch Reporter

Johnno WilsonMike Makowsky

Erin HenriquesStacy

Gage BiltoftJohn Watson

Lasaundra GibsonFaustine Rea

John MaceyMr. Lee

Betsy FoldesSVPD Missing Persons (voice)

Joseph John SchirleJonah Emmi (voice)

Julie NathansonNatalie Boyd (voice)

Michelle SparksNews Reporter #4 (voice)

Aneesh ChagantyDirector

Sev OhanianWriter

Aneesh ChagantyWriter